BAIC — Appendices

The Campbell Report of 1981 on the Australian financial system 4 spurred Australia to embark on a relatively rapid transformation from one of the most regulated financial sectors in the world to one of the more liberal. Key steps included floating the Australian dollar in December 1983, granting 40 new foreign exchange licences in June 1984, granting banking licences to 16 foreign banks in February 1985, removal of interest rate ceilings (1985-86) and restrictions on the range of activities in which banks can engage, Liberalisation of reserve requirements (1985, 1988).

Consequently, from the 1980s, the Australian banking system has transformed from one consisting of a small number of major banks, four State banks, and a very small number of minor ones, to a system with open entry where though the four major Australian banks still dominate, they are open to competition from subsidiaries of foreign banks 5 and from small and regional banks (and other deposit-taking institutions, such as building societies 6 ). Most of the new local banks were formed by consolidation of existing financial institutions such as building societies and “savings banks”.

Very few of the foreign-owned banks attempted to compete with the established local banks by setting up or acquiring a large branch network. Instead they went for niches such as merchant banking or personal banking to very rich customers. (The introduction of ATM networks in the early 1980s by the major local banks can be seen as an attempt to discourage competitors in the “retail” market.) The major exception to this was the National Mutual Royal Bank, formed by National Mutual (one of the largest local insurance companies) and Royal Bank of Canada. This rapidly built up a retail network of nearly 200 branches across Australia by acquiring local building societies.

In 1990, ANZ perceived that “deregulation” offered scope for synergy between traditional banking and the previously segregated life insurance and superannuation business, which looked likely to become a more favoured savings medium than traditional savings banks, as government encouraged (indeed compelled by legislation from 1992) workers to save for their retirements. ANZ therefore proposed a merger with National Mutual, but the Government refused to allow it, citing “national interest grounds” – essentially, too great a concentration of financial institutions within Australia was seen as anti-competitive. This raises the question: about what “market” should competition policy be concerned?

Table 2 shows a matrix of possibilities. Competition policy in Australia has been largely concerned with the bottom left quadrant, as indicated by the very title of the main regulator, the Australian Competition and Consumer Council, set up in 1975. But the management of ANZ and the big local banks are most strategically concerned with the top right quadrant: their concern is whether ANZ is big enough to fight off foreign companies who wish either to 4 Final Report of the Committee of Inquiry into the Australian Financial System , Australian Government Publishing Service, Canberra, 1981.

5 In strict legal terms, there are no “foreign” banks in Australia- rather, foreign-owned banks operate through subsidiary companies. 6 Roughly equivalent to the “savings and loans” institutions in USA. - 113 -