BAIC — IV. Case Studies of the New Economy in APEC

guilds of key professionals. 61 This is highly consistent with the empirical findings about the importance of transformation entering an economy through the import trade channel as noted below. The case study of New Economy developments in Japan also captures the flavor of transformation and deep restructuring. The case study, drafted by analysts in the Japanese Cabinet Office 62 , provides an overview of the New Economy changes taking place in Japan as a result of ICTs and evolving underlying policy conditions, rather than a specific firm. But the signs of corporate transformation are abundant.

For example the study presents data showing a shift in corporate IT spending from areas related to marginal cost savings and efficiency, such as personnel/human resources and accounting 63 , to core components of how firms compete, including management planning and procurement. As the study states: There have also been changes in the objectives of IT investment. While “speed up of operations” is becoming less important, other objectives are getting more important, such as “Strengthening business and sales force,” “Organizational reformation,” and “Reduction in procurement cost.” From this it can be seen that IT investment is being undertaken as an active corporate management strategy.

The Japan case study is also very explicit in observing that only in cases where “corporate flattening” – a Japanese way of saying restructuring – took place along with the move to ICT did total factor productivity tend to increase. (Human capital was also identified as a necessary co-factor.) Attempting to install the ICTs without permitting the change in corporate culture and behavior that comes along with greater information and fewer constraints (policy and market structure) to use that information (i.e., a more contestable marketplace) does not lead to the gains of the New Economy.

In fact it is actually value- subtracting , because it requires capital expenditure but does not produce a return on the investment. The case study offers us an example of what a shift in attitude would mean in Japan: Employment relations from now on are expected to develop more along the lines of “Treatment based on merit and ability,” “Securing human resources with priority on competitiveness and expertise.” These responses seem to foresee that enterprises will try to link IT to their competitiveness more strategically by advancing restructuring of the human resources within their organizations.

That such a shift is still required in the world’s second largest economy toward using expertise as the decisive factor in making hiring decisions says much about the “structural” aspect of Japan’s economic reform challenge. 61 See Michael Enright et al’s study of HK noting that until recently “the non-competitive delivery of non-traded services was not a matter likely to jeopardize the territory’s competitiveness;” 61 but that today it matters tremendously. 62 Prepared by International Economic Affairs Division, Cabinet Office -- Japanese Government.

63 This is not to say that incremental changes in the conduct of business functions such as HR and accounting are not important New Economy events, or do not add up – when they take place across the whole economy – to potent economic gains and transformation. - 41-