advantage has the potential to shift significantly given the investment in ICT by firms elsewhere. For this particular small family firm, the use of ICT may not be transformative, mainly because of the firm’s reliance on face-to-face and personal interaction, and a reluctance to do business or negotiate on-line. Factors including volatile technology prices and concern over on-line security contributed to this Malaysian firm's concerns. But the overarching view was that low tech approaches were just better suited for their business. A few quotes sum up their perspective: There is no doubt that the reduced costs have been a direct benefit to the bottom line.
Furthermore the accelerated operation times has reduced inventory costs. However the Internet has not resulted in an expansion of either the customer or supplier base. The clients stressed that in the industrial supply business the element of personal relationship remains crucial.... Clients were adamant that a good track record of service, reliability and a strong market reputation helped them maintain their competitive edge. [T]here were, at least in late 1999 and early 2000, very high expectations about the internet and its ability to cut business costs. However, they have not yet found that many apparent advantages have been applicable in their particular business.
As discussed earlier, this preference for the personal is prevalent in wealthy Hong Kong as well, where over 50% of SMEs appear uninterested in transforming even so much as to use e- mail. The commonality here may be smallness. It is unclear why a firm cannot maintain personal contacts and employ information technology at the same time. The Peruvian and Vietnamese cases implicitly demonstrate the need for transformation. The Vietnamese case describes an on-line medical clinic service claiming to have 6000 unique visitors a month in an Economy with only 130,000 dial-up internet users 70 . In Peru 70 Contributed by Dr. Mai Anh of Viet Nam’s Ministry of Science, Technology and Economy (MOSTE).
- 46-