covering China with an integrated network for data exchange and trade processing, with links to international networks. The case says that last year (2000), “...about 40 billion U.S. dollars export transactions used CIETNet to transmit export documents.” This achievement testifies to the transformation that has taken place using ICTs. But we also know from copious research and from senior Chinese officials themselves that serious local distortions, including intra-provincial trade barriers, prevent full rationalization of commerce. The ICTs cannot transform the market structure alone, rather central policy reform must occur in order for the network to realize its full potential.
Otherwise, regions utilizing the efficiency benefits of the network (e.g., permitting online financial services) will pull ahead while regions resisting network-borne competition in order to promote local infant firms will fall behind. The resistors will hobble the non-high tech, old economy by denying it the benefit of competitive value chain partnerships. The CIECC study correctly reveals the likely transformation of government, too, that will occur as the network is allowed to function fully:
“It [the network] also makes the governmental administration on trade more efficient and more transparent, eradicates low efficiency, arbitrary, and bureaucracy and helps to build an administration-service system of standard, efficiency, justice and transparency.” What that means is that the status quo in governance and regulatory behavior in most of China as it pertains to commercial activity is about to change – radically. This forecast is substantiated by the other two China case studies focused on the fortunes of particular businesses in China.
From the retail automation systems study we see first hand what the countervailing local forces are that must be transformed if CIECC’s network is to realize its value, and in the TCL case we can extrapolate what sorts of top level structural policy reforms will be needed to permit a Chinese success story in the journey from state owned-follower of policy to dynamic mid-sized-competitor for national market share to make the next step: to world class, world scale competitor. The case study by a small private retail automation systems company is valuable, as it is from the perspective of a firm that offers the nuts and bolts of information processing technology for the New Economy.
From the case study: [The] product is a Consumer Relationship Management software suite, which gather information about consumers and analyze demographic and purchasing characteristics in order to enable companies to improve operating margins. Profitability is increased through better targeting of marketing campaigns, early identification of attrition risks, improved management of customer service, and other technology-aided marketing and sales activities. This is precisely the kind of product that permits managers of a business to quantify the advantages and disadvantages of how they are currently using scarce capital and labor for commercial ends.
Once again, the rational reaction to that data is – so long as the market incentive exists – to transform a business using new information, because it is no longer ambiguous what is fruitful and what is wasteful in the present activities of the firm. The case study describes, however, how the normal market incentives that would bring about that - 48-