BAIC — IV. Case Studies of the New Economy in APEC

Second, public expenditure priorities can prevent adjustment quite apart from aggregate demand management efforts (though the latter is often used as a cover) when a large share of public spending goes to support specific firms for the sake of industrial policy. Not only can such efforts crowd out competitive new firms – both foreign and domestic – from acquiring the market share that is the life blood incentive for investment, but these goals crowd out more productive avenues for expenditure such as primary health and education, or environmental reclamation that national resources might otherwise be directed toward.

Finally, the tax side is fiscal spending’s twin, and it is imperative that fiscal outlays be tamed so that tax rates can be held lower enough to attract investment and innovation while still providing for basic high-return government tasks. This quote from the Korea Samsung-Tesco case study is both instructive and fascinating: Had the macroeconomic conditions been favorable, Samsung Corporation would never have considered a merger with Tesco PLC and the result would not have been as good as now.

Strategy and Planning department of Samsung-Tesco pointed out that while favorable macroeconomic condition is important and much more preferred, it is also the case that the unfavorable macroeconomic condition sometimes boosts restructuring and creates an environment for what Samsung-Tesco calls a ‘step change’…. When the organization does not have capability of conducting ‘creative destruction’, unfavorable macroeconomic conditions could stimulate the innovation process, but it should not be (and cannot be) deliberately created for its risk is too big. The message here is extremely clear:

the until recently-prevailing strategy in Korea of using fiscal subsidies directly or indirectly to offset the commercial shortcomings of firms in a changing, increasingly global economy stymied transformation which – though unpleasant to go through – is the source of subsequent corporate strength. In the end, as difficult as transition was for Samsung, it probably can be thanked for the continuing viability of countless jobs. Very little is said directly in the case studies about fiscal policy issues, aside from a pointed comment in the Canadian retail sector case study:

[I]t is important that the government provide a sound fiscal framework, low inflation regarding stable price as well as stable interest rates. It is especially true for [the] retail sector as the large merchandising firms must be convinced that the economic environment is conducive to sustaining economic growth before they make large capital investments. As this quote notes fiscal policy has an important role to play in minimizing the disruptive effects of business cycles and thus in girding investment, and that is something that many of the case studies emphasize.

Malaysia; Hong Kong, China; Peru; Japan and Korea, for example, in addition to Canada, suggested that ICT investments had been reduced by lean economic conditions (though often these were considered exogenous and hence less amenable to proper domestic fiscal action). - 51-