It is worthwhile discussing the research underlying the Table (which is presented in detailed form in Appendix 1). Survey research of US industry in 2000 (Brookes and Wahhaj) suggests cost savings ranging from 10 percent in sectors such as aerospace, paper and steel, and communications bandwidth and media advertising, to more than 20 percent in electronic components and machining, forest products, and freight transport. New research, edited by Litan and Rivlin of Brookings, takes a more comprehensive look at the impact of information technologies on productivity growth in different sectors in the US and sums up the impact on US productivity growth at between 0.25 to 0.5 percentage points.
86 Forrester Research 87 considers two inputs: “industry readiness” and “product fit” to yield a measure of “ultimate marketplace saturation” for how much different industry sectors might use networked ICTs. Computing and electronics for example has a measure of greater than 70 percent “ultimate marketplace saturation” because the industry is “ready” and the “product fit” is high. For industrial equipment and supplies, the industry is “ready” but the “product fit” is not as good (since a great degree of customization is common); thus a measure of only 60- 70 percent “ultimate marketplace saturation”. And so on.
These measures of both “industry readiness” and “product fit” help to characterize which sectors are or will be transformed the most by the use of ICTs, and therefore, which sectors may demand a heavier use of networked information technologies by their supply chain partners in the APEC economies. EITO from Europe 88 presents another analysis of how e-commerce is affecting industry sectors there. This study rates European industries and partners by internal use of the networked ICTs (e.g. whether firms in the sector are reorienting their internal organization and operations toward using the Internet) and external use of networked ICTs (e.g.
whether external relationships and marketing are being done via the Internet). The two scores weighted-up yield the overall score for the sector. By and large, the analysis suggests that US 86 Robert E. Litan and Alice M. Rivlin (2001), Beyond the Dot.Coms: The Economic Promise of the Internet, Brookings Institutions, July 2001 draft. 87 ( http://ebizchronicle.com/backgrounders/march/forrest_b2opportunity_onlinetrade.htm ) last visited June 26, 2001.
88 EITO (2001), European Information Technology Observatory 2000 Millennium Edition Part Two, The Impact of E-Commerce on Five Vertical Sectors (prepared by GartnerConsulting in close collaboration with EITO Task Force and Enterprise DG of the European Commission). - 72- Table: Technology Transformation Intensity: Benchmark Foods 4 Consumer goods and textiles 3 Energy, chemicals, natural resources 1 Pharmaceuticals 4 Forest/paper products 4 Steel/metals and metal products 1 Industrial equipment & Supplies 3 Electronic Components 5 Autos 3