BAIC — BAIC User Manual: Все, что нужно знать о вашем автомобиле

FIXED OPS JOURNAL LEGAL LANE Calif. court rejects service director’s suit over fi ring a mechanic in 2015. A few months later, the store told all employ- ees to sign an arbitration agreement in order to keep their jobs. thing because Nickel refused to pay for the re- pair, it is hard to fathom how it could be found to have negligently repaired Nickel’s Flex or was negligent for allowing the vehicle to re- main in storage on its lot.” T e California Court of Appeal rejected a suit by a former service and parts director who claimed a T ousand Oaks dealership group wrongly fi red him after 13 years for raising concerns about workplace safety. Williams refused and was fi red.

He claimed that the arbitration agreement denied his rights under federal anti-discrimination laws, and that the dealership discriminated on the basis of race and disability in rejecting him for a job as a lube tech. Nickel’s lawyer, Kenneth Wright, called the dealership’s conduct “textbook for how to alienate future customers.” He said he has asked the Louisiana Supreme Court to review the appellate ruling. Ernest Sumen alleged that Silver Star Auto- motive Group, terminated him in 2012 for complaining about an unsafe hoist that he had red-tagged as out of service.

Howard, who signed the agreement, claim- ed he was wrongfully fi red after he com- plained about alleged race-based pay dispari- ties in the service department. Both plaintiff s fi led complaints with the federal Equal Em- ployment Opportunity Commission. Aston Martin owner sues dealership over repairs He worked at the group’s Mercedes-Benz and Jaguar dealerships, according to court fi l- ings. Silver Star countered that its action was jus- tifi ed because Sumen failed to properly over- see repairs of equipment and remedy unsafe shop working conditions. It said technicians continued to use the tagged hoist, which he hadn’t repaired or replaced.

What happens when a $200,000 luxury car needs $135,546 in crash repairs and the owner lacks full insurance? For the owner of a 2014 Aston Martin DB9, the response was a lawsuit against the British Columbia dealership that sold the vehicle and made some repairs, an independent body shop that did the bulk of the work, and the manufacturer. Edmunds upheld the class-action arbitra- tion waiver, and said mandatory arbitration doesn’t undermine the EEOC’s enforcement powers in discrimination cases. In its unanimous decision, the court ruled that Sumen didn’t provide enough evidence that Silver Star retaliated against him for re- porting the defective hoist.

It cited testimony from the group’s human resources director that she fi red Sumen for not ensuring work- place safety, which the court said “he might have done by enforcing the hoist’s decommis- sion. T e dealership’s lawyer didn’t respond to a request for comment. Jessica Liu accused the defendants of breach of contract, collusion, and taking ad- vantage of her “considerable personal wealth,” the fact that English isn’t her fi rst language, and her lack of full insurance. T e defendants denied wrongdoing, calling the suit before the British Columbia Supreme Court frivolous.

Court nixes negligence award against dealership A Louisiana Ford dealership successfully appealed a $140,000-plus judgment against it involving a vehicle that it examined but didn’t repair. T ey fi led a counterclaim for defamation and breach of contract. “Sumen essentially admitted to the failure when he admitted he was unaware employees continued to use the defective hoist,” the court added. Milo Nickel Jr. alleged that his new 2009 Ford Flex suff ered problems with its Sync sys- tem, warning lights, indicators and air condi- tioning after crash-related repairs. T e dealer- ship where he bought the vehicle, now out of business, and an independent collision facili- ty made those repairs.

Liu bought the DB9 from Aston Martin Van- couver in 2015 and damaged its right front in a single-car crash six months later, according to court fi lings. T e dealership made some re- pairs, including new brake pads and rotors. It recommended that Burrard Autostrasse Colli- sion, one of Canada’s only two authorized re- pair shops for the vehicle, handle the rest of the work. Lee Sherman, a lawyer for Silver Star, called the ruling “righteous and fair.” Sumen’s law- yers didn’t respond to a request for comment. Mandatory arbitration OK’d for service employees T ree years later, he brought the Flex to Bolton Ford in Lake Charles, reporting that it wouldn’t start.

However, a technician found that it started every time. A porter fi red by a suburban Detroit dealer- ship after he refused to sign a mandatory arbi- tration agreement can’t pursue discrimina- tion and retaliation claims, a federal judge ruled. According to court fi lings, Burrard’s esti- mate initially was $23,969, but increased to more than $130,000. Liu paid a $50,000 de- posit but claimed she later canceled the repair authorization. T e dealership made “multiple attempts to diagnose and fi x the problems Nickel claimed to be having,” the Court of Appeal said.

It rec- ommended replacing the power distribution box and electrical wiring harness for $2,500, but Nickel refused and “eff ectively abandoned his vehicle at the dealership,” the court added. U.S. District Judge Nancy Edmunds also ruled that a former service technician who signed the agreement, which prohibits class-action arbitration, must arbitrate his in- dividual claims and can’t pursue a class-ac- tion suit on behalf of employees of All Pro Nis- san of Dearborn, Mich. However, the judge has agreed to reconsider that decision, ac- cording to plaintiff s’ lawyer Shereef Akeel.

T e shop completed the work and is holding the vehicle pending payment of the $85,586 balance and $200-a-day storage charges, court documents said. “Bolton Ford inspected the car but did not repair it because plaintiff would not agree to pay for the repairs,” said dealership lawyer Robert Maxwell. Nickel sued Ford Motor Co. to rescind his purchase and sued Bolton Ford for negligent repair. He won at a non-jury trial. T e dealership’s lawyer declined to com- ment. Liu’s lawyer didn’t respond to a request for comment. But the appellate court said:

“Considering that Bolton Ford never actually repaired any- ---- Eric Freedman foj@autonews.com According to the ruling, All Pro Nissan hired Brian Williams as a porter and Jay Howard as PAGE 8 AUGUST 2018