BAIC — BAIC User Manual: Все, что нужно знать о вашем автомобиле

ments by senior technicians, Robinson told Fixed Ops Journal : “It’s not uncommon for me to talk to fi xed ops directors and hear, ‘T e av- erage tenure in my shop is 28 years, and I am losing 60 percent of my techs in the next fi ve years to retirement.’ ” Flat-rate pay: The villain that may never go away Turnover costs T e opportunity cost of the tech shortage is huge. Experts estimate the typical technician generates $1,000 in gross revenue per work day. A job unfi lled for 90 days means a potential loss of $90,000 to a dealership’s fi xed operations. And smaller margins on new- and-used vehicle sales and fi nance and insurance already are putting extra revenue pressure on fi xed ops. T ALAN L.

ADLER foj@autonews.com cently switched to hourly pay for its techs. “When I worked at the dealership years ago, it was terrifying, some of the things that happened in the bays.” he causes of the service tech shortage are many. But Hire- ology CEO Adam Robinson calls dealership pay plans “the big- gest issue we have in tech retention.” Seyfer recalls that a frequent repair on the Ford Windstar minivan was so simple that techs would replace the part even if the fi x wasn’t needed, just to boost their pay. Nearly three out of four new-vehicle dealerships still use a fl at-rate system, pay- ing technicians a set amount per completed job rather than an hourly wage.

T e fastest techs can earn productivity bo- nuses. In a 2016 survey Carlisle conducted with Automotive News , dealers said that if they had as many techs as they wanted, they would be able to increase fi xed ops revenue by 17 per- cent. But for many dealerships, the trend is moving in the opposite direction. “It’s all based on speed — the faster I go, the more money I make,” Seyfer says. Service, he adds, “is not cyclical. It doesn’t have to do with the weather.

It has to do with peo- ple’s paychecks.” T e annual turnover rate for the most- skilled dealership technicians rose to 27.2 percent in 2016 from 25.1 percent a year earli- er, NADA’s 2017 Dealership Workforce Study But critics, who call fl at-rate plans antiquated, say they val- ue speed over quality of repair and tend to put younger and less experienced techs at a dis- advantage. Yet the fl at rate system is so embedded in dealerships, says Mattia Janigo, a manager at Carlisle & Co., that the con- sulting fi rm will recommend against trying to dismantle it in its forthcoming report on best practices for service departments.

Carlisle visited 50 automaker-recommended dealer- ships to gather information and impres- sions for the study, he adds. concluded. Almost seven in 10 newly hired techs in 2016 were millennials, born between the early 1980s and early 2000s. “If I am in another industry, I am paying you for the time you spend here,” Robinson told Fixed Ops Journal . “When you pay your techs on a rate card, you are putting all the risk on them.” Janigo: Hedging on fl at-rate critique T e average dealership technician is 40 years old and has 19 years of tech experience, according to the Carlisle survey of 15,000 techs in 2016. T e study found that the typi- cal tech would not recom- mend the career to a friend.

A survey this year of 4,700 repair pro- fessionals, most of them service techs, by the National Institute for Automotive Service Excellence (ASE) found that 73 percent of dealerships pay technicians a fl at rate, compared with 17 percent of af- termarket repair shops. Kraybill: Skilled techs hired away “We had heard all sorts of anecdotes of how fl at-rate is the single destructive force that is ruining our chance to keep technicians,” Janigo says. “Over the course of the project, we’ve hedged that a little bit.” Ted Kraybill, CEO of ESi Trends in Largo, Fla.

, which compiles the annual workforce survey for NADA, notes that techs who leave their jobs don’t necessarily retire or go to work for another dealership. “T e fl at-rate pay system is very bad for skills,” says Donny Seyfer, executive offi - cer of the National Automotive Training Task Force and co-owner of an indepen- dent shop in Wheat Ridge, Colo., that re- Janigo says other factors, including the strength of a dealership’s management and career coaching for technicians, may matter more than its pay plan in encour- aging them to stay. “In a lot of the areas of the country, skilled techs are hired away from automotive service to oil service” and other industries, Kraybill notes.

Median pay for dealership techs in 2016 ranged from $29,024 for a lube tech to $69,703 for a master technician, NADA says. T e me- dian pay — half earned less, half more — for service advisers was $62,333. In comparison, the Bureau of Labor Statistics says median pay last year for an aircraft technician was $61,260. are open more hours, you need more techs to cover it,” he notes. growing share of repairs require computer and electronics skills rather than mechanical ones. Barely 1 percent of dealership techs are women, compared with 19 percent of dealer- ship employees overall, NADA says.

Culture clash T e culture of dealership service depart- ments may also contribute to the tech short- age. For many shops, industry observers say, that culture hasn’t changed much since the mid-20th century — mostly male, sometimes crude. T e obsolete image of the “grease mon- key” too often persists, despite determined industry eff orts to eradicate it. “I don’t think dealers can completely fi x that issue,” Robinson says. “But it would be inex- cusable for a dealer to lose a female techni- cian because its fi xed ops culture was hostile.” T e average tech works 44 hours a week, the NADA study says. Some dealerships assign techs to a 40-hour work week made up of four 10-hour shifts.

T e four-day week provides consistent time off , but presents other chal- lenges, Kraybill says. Donny Seyfer, executive offi cer of the Na- tional Automotive Training Task Force , notes “If you cut down on number of hours and Shop life can still be dirty, even though a see SHORTAGE, Page 14 AUGUST 2018 PAGE 13