FIXED OPS JOURNAL HANDS ON TOOL BOX Automakers must help dealers limit spending on costly shop devices O ur in-depth look at collision repair in the June issue of Fixed Ops Journal covered the problems dealers face as they contemplate entering or staying in the body shop business. But another topic needs to be considered: the unnecessarily high cost of tools. It’s time for automakers to stop requiring dealerships to buy diff erent brands of tools that perform the same functions in the same ways. RICHARD TRUETT rtruett@crain.com Fixed Ops Journal Say a rivet gun can insert a self- piercing rivet at a depth of 40 millimeters at 4,400 pounds of force and meets an automaker’s repair requirements.
A dealership should not have to buy another rivet gun of a diff erent brand — at a typical cost of $8,000 to $12,000 , depending on manufacturer and capability — to meet another manufacturer’s certifi cation standards. Yet that often happens. It’s the same with scan tools. Look at the approved tool repair catalogs of Mercedes-Benz, Audi and Jaguar Land Rover. Each luxury automaker requires diff erent brands of the same basic tools. Welders, scanners, glue guns — they all do the same essential jobs. Aluminum Repair Network to have a specifi c set — not brand — of tools to repair the aluminum-intensive CT6 sedan.
But if a dealership doesn’t buy factory-approved tools, the manufacturer likely won’t certify it for collision work. Without that certifi cation, the body shop might not have access to some repair parts. Collision customers who seek factory-approved repairs would have to go elsewhere. Specs, not brand A dealership that was just getting into aluminum body repair could have spent $40,000 to $50,000 on shop equipment to work on the CT6. GM helped dealers keep costs down by writing the tool requirements to a specifi cation, not a brand. So if a dealer’s body shop already had tools that could meet the CT6 repair requirements, the shop was good to go.
Service departments that lack the right tools or shop equipment can’t buy certain structural repair parts for the CT6. Costly duplication “Our customers have to make a decision as to which programs they are going to participate in based on what equipment they have to buy to satisfy requirements,” says Nick Notte, senior vice president of I-CAR, the Inter-Industry Conference on Auto Collision Repair , which provides training and education in collision repair. “In the collision space, we work with other OEMs to understand where they are,” says John Eck, GM’s collision manager for customer care and aftersales. “And that can get pretty pricey,” Notte notes.
Jeb Balise owns a group of 24 franchised dealerships in New England. He also operates four body shops that repair all brands of vehicles, even makes that his new-car stores don’t sell. He says dueling tool standards are a source of expensive frustration. “Our Cadillac network overlaps well with other vehicle brands that have aluminum unibodies,” Eck says. “And the tools and equipment apply across the board to many of those brands.” T at should be the industry standard. Ford Motor Co. says it also is working to reduce the number of special tools it requires of dealers. Balise says he tries to buy tools that will satisfy multiple automakers, but that isn’t always possible.
Instead of losing an automaker’s repair certifi cation, Balise will buy the expensive tool the factory demands. “Our design for repairability allows us to develop less invasive repair procedures and increase effi ciencies to minimize requirements for special service tools,” according to Ford’s collision repair team. “It might mean it doesn’t get used as often as you like, or practically speaking it wasn’t the best investment,” Balise told me. “But it is the cost of doing business for us. Tool manufacturers have a role as well. Making tools more versatile and adjustable could meet numerous automakers’ specifi cations. T at would save dealers money and boost sales.
“We have to keep our certifi cations,” he adds, “and we want consumers to have the peace of mind that they are going to the right place.” As we move into an era of vehicle electrifi cation and lightweight materials, tools inevitably will get more complex and expensive. Now is the time for industrywide tool standards. General Motors requires dealerships that enroll in its Cadillac AUGUST 2018 PAGE 37