MIL-HDBK-304C Amplification Factor = Maximum Acceleration m 1 / Maximum Acceleration m 2 Β 1 = Fraction of critical damping of the element across spring k 1 Β 2 = Fraction of critical damping of the element across spring k 2 k 1 = Spring rate of fragile element of packaged item k 2 = Spring rate of linear cushioning m 1 = lumped mass of fragile element of packaged article m 2 = lumped mass of packaged item m 3 = lumped mass of outer container v = velocity ω 1 = Radian frequency of vibration of package item-cushioning system (k 1 /m 1 ) ω 2 = Radian frequency of vibration of an element of a packaged item (k 2 /m 2 ) Therefore, in order to effect a standard fragility rating procedure, all fragility assessment, cushioning design methods, and test procedures to determine shock transmission to packaged items considered herein are based upon peak acceleration rating of the basic rigid structures of items.
In those instances where none of the accessible portions of items are relatively rigid, the item should be enclosed or blocked in position inside a relatively rigid interior container; acceleration measurements should be based upon the peak acceleration of the substituted case corresponding to damage or malfunction of the enclosed item. Paragraph 6.3.2 discusses techniques for "immobilizing" items. 5.2.1 Fragility Assessment. The objective of the fragility test is to determine by laboratory test methods the maximum shock an item can sustain during shipment before damage will occur. Cushioning systems lower the shock levels felt by the item so the item is less likely to break.
5.2.1.1 Shock Duration. The time duration of the shock pulse is an important consideration. Many times there is confusion between the acceleration levels felt in aircraft (e.g. 2 G’s) and those felt with packaged items. The difference is the duration of the shock. Aircraft acceleration has duration of seconds so only very small accelerations can be tolerated, while cushioned packaged items have a duration of milliseconds. The duration of most acceleration-time pulses that cushioned packaged items received because of dropping from heights of 18 to 36 inches range from 10 to 40 milliseconds.
When determining fragility levels for items, it is important to remember that package system drops have a very short duration. See 5.2.1.4 for estimating fragility ratings. Fragility Testing is the best way to determine the fragility levels. Also Table V gives a listing of Typical Fragility Ratings. (7)(21) 5.2.1.2 Fragility Assessment By Testing. The most accurate method for fragility assessment of the item (not the container) is by testing the item until damage occurs. The concept that is considered to be most appropriate is the Damage Boundary Concept. 5.2.1.3 Damage Boundary Concept.
The Damage Boundary concept of fragility determination advanced by Newton ( 11 )( 12 ) is based on a rectangular waveform shock pulse. This pulse is used to approximate the complex waveforms seen by the item during impact. The Damage Boundary Curve depicted in Figure 5-2, can be defined for any particular item through testing of the item on a programmable shock machine. See 9.1.17 for the referenced test procedure and a photograph of the programmable shock machine. The Damage Boundary Curve relates peak shock acceleration on the vertical axis and total velocity change on the horizontal axis to product damage.
A point or combination of peak acceleration and velocity change that fall above and to the right of the curve results in product damage. Point C is such a combination. However, Points A and B will not result in damage. Point B, although it represents a relatively high acceleration level, it also represents a very low velocity 19 Downloaded from https://www.everyspec.com