MIL-HDBK-304C 5.2.1.4 Fragility Assessment By Estimation. While testing of items to determine equitable fragility ratings is desirable for cushioning design, on many occasions, such testing is infeasible. Some common reasons for this are: (1) Sufficiently accurate testing and recording equipment is not available. (2) Only a few expensive items are to be shipped and, therefore, the potential savings to be realized by accurate cushioning design are insignificant compared to the expense of fragility testing. (3) Records from previously conducted fragility tests of similar items are available for estimation of the fragility ratings.
It is important that the packaging designer interpret clearly the results of environmental shock tests, such as those specified in MIL-STD-810. The shock levels required by such environmental performance tests are intended to simulate operational conditions, but not necessarily the shipping environment--which is often more severe. Unfortunately because of item cost or uniqueness, designers rarely perform actual fragility tests. As an alternative, the package designers merely use the operational environmental test shock input values as the fragility ratings for the items for cushioning design purposes.
The operational environmental shock test values for items are sometimes only about 20 percent of actual fragility ratings. The packaging engineer must differentiate between operational environmental test conditions and actual fragility values, since the accuracy of their cushioning design will vary with the accuracy of their assessment of the design parameters. In some instances, a particular kind of item is shipped in successive lots. Once shipping records (including damage claims) have been obtained, redesign of the packaging for greater efficiency is possible for subsequent shipments.
To accomplish this, it is necessary to estimate the fragility of the item on the basis of the known performance of the cushioning used in previous shipments and to compute the most economical cushioning system. The following example will illustrate how shipping records might be used to estimate the fragility rating of an item. PROBLEM: A rigid 8-inch (200-mm) cubical item that weighs 12 pounds (5.5 kg) has been shipped successfully in a package utilizing 8 x 8 x 4--inch (200 x 200 x 100--mm) polyethylene pads. During a subsequent shipment involving the same kind of items and containers but 8 x 8 x 3--inch (200 x 200 x 75--mm) polyethylene pads, some items were damaged by impact.
The maximum drop height is unknown. Estimate the fragility rating of the items. SOLUTION: Since both the maximum height of drop and item fragility rating are unknown, it is necessary to assume a fixed value for one of these parameters in order to calculate the other. Accordingly, assume a flat drop from 30 inches (0.75 m).
(For purposes of illustration in this problem, assume that a check of cushioning performance data indicates that, for the loading condition involved, and 8 x 8 x 3--inch (200 x 200 x 75--mm) polyethylene pad will produce a peak acceleration of 97 G; a 4-inch (100-mm) pad would produce a peak acceleration of 53 G.) Therefore, the mean fragility rating of this kind of item probably lies between 53 and 97 G. If desirable, the package designer should base the cushioning redesign upon a fragility rating of about 50 G and a 30-inch (0.75m) flat drop. Note: The design methods involving the use of peak acceleration-static-stress curves are described in 5.4. 5.2.2 Product Improvement Feedback.
Based upon the results of the fragility tests, it may be desirable to strengthen the product rather than ship each one inside an expensive package. Tradeoffs between product cost, product reliability, and packaging costs should be identified and 21 Downloaded from https://www.everyspec.com