to permit financial service innovation and provision in a new way, and a competitive finance industry where firms foreign or domestic strive to expand the utility of their services for consumers and businesses. The Canadian retail case study shows how retailers are integrating all financial tasks into their B2B networking practices.
By contrast, the China case study documents that similar types “of simple financial service [are] off limits to the private sector in China, not obtainable from any of the state-owned banks, and therefore not, currently, an option.” The biggest problem identified by Samsung-Tesco in Korea was also a government prohibition against private businesses offering new financial services to customers who wanted them.
In Peru, “Many projects to build Internet focused SMEs have been halted because of the high interest rates in the Peruvian financial system.” The global provision of financial services we see in the Australian study makes it increasingly fruitless to maintain restrictions on innovation in finance domestically. At the very least, domestic citizens will be highly aware of the superior value and quality of financial services offshore, and therefore be discontent with their local providers. Moreover informal arbitraging to take advantage of the value elsewhere will emerge and entrepreneurs will go abroad to access efficient finance.
It is also clear how important the prudential function is for financial deepening to lead to long-term benefits. In Malaysia, the studied firm worried that online finance: “…depended on the quality of management and supervision. ‘We are concerned about the calibre of the people inputting data and supervising the process.’” In Viet Nam, the lack of regulations covering financial transactions on the internet leads the entrepreneur in the case to be cautious about on-line payments.
Even the case study from advanced Japan fretted that “we cannot deny that IT has served to destabilize financial and capital markets.” These concerns are totally justified, they range from the microeconomic needs such as consumer protection to macro concerns like interest rates, and they require a trusted and competent organization of financial regulators and policy reformers to remedy. Economic transformation yields benefits, in terms of profitability, jobs created, quality of life and environment and prevented adjustment shocks in the future. But it requires inputs and finance is perhaps the most important one.
The financial sector must send some of the most sensitive, critical and powerful signals through the whole economy in the form of the prices it sets for finance, therefore it is critically important that it performs efficiently. The financial sector itself must be permitted to transform to be viable in the New Economy, but then it must be empowered by its independence to help all other sectors transform as well. Ultimately, given the size of the rest of the economy compared to the finance sector, it is most important that this input to transformation is provided efficiently, and of very little importance whether it is provided by a domestic firm. - 53-