Trade and Investment Policy The case studies offer plenty of examples of and support for the broadly understood notion that liberalization of trade and investment policies is key to stoking domestic productivity growth. The inflow of foreign know-how, technology, competition, culture, products, and finance, as well as the “inflow” of foreign demand, can each bring about transformation and restructuring in domestic firms.
Failure of policy to encourage openness to trade and investment conversely defers that restructuring, and during that deferral – especially during moments of profound technological change in the external economy such as is taking place today – domestic commercial prowess will generally erode. The case studies mostly reflect the upside of the New Economy for trade and investment openness. In Hong Kong, China, the Trade Development Council may now process over 1 million inquiries about local businesses a year.
The CIETNet e-commerce network in China is expected to help precipitate a fully paperless trading environment there by 2010, which is expected to also help eliminate false trading license problems between China and the US and other economies. (Indeed, the CIETNet case study notes the importance of APEC in helping coordinate progress toward that paperless environment.) Peruvians send large amounts of goods home through internet commerce, along with $800 million a year, and the customs authorities hope to be paperless in the medium term. Competition successfully impelled the Australian banking industry to dramatically improve competitiveness.
But for each of these successes and hopes, there is a dark side: the prospect that for whatever reasons, the domestic policy changes needed to implement these improvements to the trade environment will not happen everywhere at once, resulting in at least temporary new comparative advantages for early movers and corresponding disadvantages for laggards. The implications of this are dealt with at length below, in the section on Digital Divide . Competition and Legal At the macro level, competition policy must support an efficient market structure outcome. Consider the following quote from the Canadian case on the subject of market structure.
“Not only is competition fierce, but firms are also becoming more uncertain of their competitors’ identity. In the retail sector, the traditional value chain of supplier, distributor, retail and customer is changing rapidly. The Internet adds to this insecurity, as prominent manufacturers now sell their products directly over the web - bypassing whole sellers, distributors and retailers. As a result, retail organizations are often faced with the difficult situation of competing among both other retailers and their own suppliers in certain cases.” This concern from the business perspective has an analogue for policymakers:
it is increasingly challenging, yet increasingly important, to estimate the market contestability results (and hence consumer welfare implications) of new horizontal and vertical arrangements among firms. Policymakers must take heed of the confusion even among firms about market power to redouble domestic efforts to provide fair trade governance, taking care not to stifle innovation in the process, so that the New Economy is characterized for easier entry and exit from market. - 54-