BAIC — IV. Case Studies of the New Economy in APEC

At the micro level, the competition regime must permit productive firms to use ICTs to create efficient business models and take commercial risks without arbitrary restrictions on scope and scale of business. One case study of China described the effects of market licensing and structure authorities that are still more concerned with the welfare of a handful of threatened producers than the welfare of the myriad of consumers. “[R]egulatory restrictions on operating retail establishments across provincial lines make it difficult for the company to grow enough to increase efficiency by lowering overhead costs.

[L]icense-scope restrictions make it hard to come up with internal financing arrangements to facilitate coordinated, group activity. [G]eneral retailing licenses, permitting sales of different product lines, cannot be obtained by small or private companies. Instead, to conduct its business, the company must use surrogates to act as the seller-of-record for the various product lines.” Not only does such a situation harm consumers, but it hobbles what ought to be a new generation of competitive firms from taking off because they cannot access such services, while new foreign competitors post-WTO most certainly will be able to even if they consume them offshore for onshore use.

In instances, the pro-competition function of government must be to actively look for potential sources of competition to incumbent domestic firms. This is why in Australia the “roles of government that have facilitated e-commerce include encouraging competition in telecommunications (and thus innovation and lower costs)”. There are also indications in the case studies of how important reforms to the basic legal environment are, including of course sound regulatory stances in areas discussed above (fiscal policy, financial, trade, etc.), and just as importantly deregulatory moves where needed.

There wariness of businesspeople to use online modalities for commerce expressed in many case studies (e.g., Malaysia) reflects the fact the in many Asian economies informal means to approximate a predictable legal environment have been fashioned over time through personal relationships and individual, local political leadership – such as a mayor in a port town ensuring foreign investors are not cheated even though national legal mechanisms are not fully in place to guarantee that. The promise of the networked economy must inherently go beyond such a bundle of local “islands” of legality to take advantage of broad economies of scope and scale unbounded by geography.

If the power of information cannot be used because only a fraction of jurisdictions have a sufficient legal environment to support its use, then the losses to an economy are exponential. This is why the low legal risk opportunities such as transmitting export documents have already gone on line in a case study such as the China CIETNet, while the higher risk but higher value added opportunities such as managing intra- firm payments online have not.

Although it does not arise in the case studies, nor does it come up in conversation too much in Asia, a taxonomy of legal and regulatory reforms conducive to a maximum growth outcome in the New Economy would not be complete without mention of property rights – including the disposition ownership of state owned enterprise assets. The Report does not propose a - 55-