US Army Materiel Command AMCP 706-197 — AMCP 706-197 Reliability Prediction Handbook — US Army Engineering Design Guide PDF

Downloaded from https://www.everyspec.com - 706-197 difficulty typically arises when there ae two ed summary and analysis of many k-out-of-n "opposite" failure modes: open - short, dud - systems. premature, too soon - too late, high - low, etc.; then at least two logic charts are neces- 7-6.2 VOTING TECHNIQUES sary for the one physical system. Very often a redundant feature for one mode turns out to Voting ordinarily is associated with digital be a series feature for the other mode. For electronic circuits, although some circuits for example, features which decrease the proba- analog electronic systems have appeared in bility of prematures, will usually increase the the literature.

It does not appcar to be appli- probability of duds. The Bibliography at the cable at all to mechanical systems. end of this chapter shows sources of further A voter has n active inputs, the output information. corresponds to the inputs which are the same for more than n/2 of the inputs. In most hard- 7-6.1 k-OUT-OF-n SYSTEMS ware implementations, n = 3, and two inputs A k-out-of-n:G-system has n units and is determine the output. If a unit fails (and the Good(u)-if-and :-ytlehast k units are i failure is somehow sensed), the failed unit can Good (up) if and only if at least k units are be removed and the voter can be restructured. Good (up).

If n = 3 and one unit fails without being re- A k-out-of-n:F-system has n units and is moved, then n = 2 and all must agree, in order Failed (down) if and only if at least k units for a signal to be passed on. If those two dis- are Failed (down). agree, then the designer has to decide what to A series system is a 1-out-of-n:F (n-out- do. Refs. 1, 2, and 4 discuss this situation and of-n:G)-system--i.e., if 1 unit fails, the system give some other references. fails-al units must be good for the system to It is possible to have some spares for some be good. voters, e.g., each element could be a k-out-of- A parallel system is usually taken to be a n subsystem.

The voters themselves can be 1-out-of-n:G (n-out-of-n:F)-system--i.e., if 1 arranged in a voting fashion. Refs. 1 and 4 unit is good, the system is good--all units describe many of the possibilities for redun- must be failed for the system to fail. dancy in computers. Refs. 2 and 3 give many of the formulas that are useful in analyzing A k-out-of-n:F system is an (n - k + 1)- these redundancies. outof-n :G-system; and a kout-of-n :G-system is an (n - k + 1)-out-of-n:F-system. Some- 7-6.3 OTHER SYSTEMS times the name parallel-system i used synon- ymously with a k-out-of-n system.

Since the Voting techniques can be combined with term parallel is ambiguous, it is best avoided k-out-of-n systems to enhance hardware relia. when accurate description is needed, The bility along with masking of faults which need k-out-of-n:G or k-out-Of-n:F notations are not be permanent. Very elaborate redundan- much to be preferred. cy techniques are best avoided unless an ex- A k-out-of-n system is also an ambiguous tremely thorough investigation, both theoreti- phrase and is used both ways in the literature. cal and practical, has been made of the pro- It is best to use the :G or :F notation when posed system.

Coverage is a term used to de- accurate description is needed, and to define scribe the detection-switching-retention pro- it. cess in redundancy. In order for automatic Thi.. k-outof-n system is usually easy to redundancy to be effective, failed units must analyze if the redundancy is either hot or cold be detected accurately and without false a- larms, then the spare unit (smehow known and the switching is perfect. The general case t e od sabe swithe h e n- for warm redundancy and imperfect switching to be good) must be switched in, and the in- has not been solved in general.

Some results formation that the system was processing can- arp available for small n and constant failure not be mangled during the operation. rates for each unit. Ref. 3 provides an extend- There are redundant (nonvoting) systems 7.4